Mold Bacteria Consulting Services

Serving Ontario and British Columbia

  • Home
  • About MBS
  • Services
    • Mold Inspection
    • Bacteria Testing
    • Bioburden Testing
    • Legionella Investigation
    • Online Training
  • Equipment/Supplies
  • iBlog
  • Kids’ Corner
    • School Science Fair Projects
    • Bacteria Pictures
    • Fungal Pictures
  • Contact Us
  • Login
You are here: Home / Archives for Micro-5

Non-viable Fungal Air Sampling Alone May Not Be Adequate

Jackson Kung'u

Non-viable Air Sampling

 

 

 

VersaTrap air sampling casette Air-O-Cell air sampling casette Allergenco air sampling casette

Indoor air sampling for airborne fungi is frequently conducted to assess the levels of fungal contamination and subsequently the potential risk to building occupants. It is also used to determine if there was hidden mould growth in the building or to determine the effectiveness of remediation procedures. One of the most cited advantages of non-viable air sampling is that detection of fungal structures (spores, hyphal fragments, etc) is not dependent on their viability or the suitability of agar media. Non-viable air samples are collected with samplers such as Air-O-Cell, Allergenco, VersaTrap, Burkard, Cyclex, Cyclex-d and Micro-5 among others. The spores (whether viable or dead) and other particulates are trapped on the sticky surface of the spore trap and can then be directly enumerated and identified under a microscope. Since both viable and nonviable spores can be enumerated, an efficient non-viable air sampler is expected to give a better estimate of the level of airborne fungal contamination than a viable air sampler.

Viable Air Sampling

Picture of Colony Forming Units: CFUViable air samples are often collected on agar media either in strips (if using Reuter Centrifugal Sampler) or in Petri-dishes for Andersen sampler. Unlike non-viable air sampling, detection and subsequent enumeration and identification of airborne fungal particulates collected on growth media depends on whether the spores and hyphal fragments are viable and whether the media used can support their growth into colonies. For this reason, colony counts are usually lower than spore counts. Even if all the fungal structures were viable, colony counts are likely to be lower than the spore/hyphal fragment counts because what is counted as a single colony could have developed from more than a single spore or hyphal fragment. In one study it was found that the ratios between the total fungal spores collected by the Burkard sampler and the viable fungi collected by the Andersen sampler ranged between 0.29 and 7.61.

Non-viable Air Sample

Picture of Chaetomium and Aspergillus/Penicillium sporesIs Non-viable Fungal Air Sampling Alone Adequate? In most cases viable air sampling is only used in situations where identification of the moulds to species level is required. However, our observation in the lab seems to suggest use of spore traps alone may not be adequate for airborne fungal sampling. On many occasions we have recovered moulds in viable samples that were not observed in non-viable samples even when viable and non-viable samples were taken side by side. For example Chaetomium and Stachybotrys spores, which are fairly easy to identify from spore traps have appeared in viable samples, yet, they were not detected from the non-viable samples. We have also observed that although non-viable sampling gives higher counts than viable sampling in most cases, this is not always the case. There are many factors that can contribute to these “unexpected” results.

Conclusion

Picture of Viable Air Samples On RCS Agar StripsSince both non-viable and viable air sampling have limitations, using either method singly is not adequate. To obtain conclusive information on the level of contamination and the diversity of airborne fungi in a building, taking both viable and non-viable air samples is preferable. We recommend the Calgary Health Region’s protocol, “Fungal Air Testing, Investigation and Reporting Requirements for Residential Marihuana Grow Operations (Revised May 2006)”. With few exceptions, the protocol requires that fungal air sampling consist of both viable samples (e.g. RCS or similar) and non-viable samples (e.g., Air-O-Cell) taken side by side.

References

Adhikari A., Sen M.M., Gupta-Bhattacharya S., Chanda S. (2004). Airborne viable, non-viable, and allergenic fungi in a rural agricultural area of India: A 2-year study at five outdoor sampling stations. Science of the Total Environment, 326 (1-3), pp. 123-141.

Calgary Health Region (2006). “Fungal Air Testing, Investigation and Reporting Requirements for Residential Marihuana Grow Operations (Revised May 2006)”.

Filed Under: Fungi, Microbial Sampling Tagged With: air sampling, Air-O-Cell, airborne fungal spores, Allergenco, Burkard, Cyclex, Cyclex-d, fungal contamination, Micro-5, mould growth, non-viable samples, spores, VersaTrap, viable

What’s New?

  • Indoor Air Quality Testing in Toronto, Ontario
  • Air Quality Testing in Vancouver, BC
  • Mold Testing in Toronto, Ontario
  • Mold Testing in Vancouver, BC
  • Salmonella food poisoning and symptoms
May 2025
S M T W T F S
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031
« Jun    

Salmonella food poisoning and symptoms

Salmonella food poisoning has been a growing concern in recent news. It has frequently lead to recalls of beef, salads and organic products and, even peanut butter products. Salmonella food poisoning occurs when one eats raw or undercooked foods such meat, poultry, eggs or egg products. Properly cooked food can get contaminated with Salmonella if […]

Legionella pneumophila – Guidelines for Laboratory Interpretation

Legionella pneumophila is a Gram negative, aerobic bacteria that is characterized as an opportunistic pathogen. It is the cause of Legionnaires’ Disease, a severe form of pneumonia and, it is the cause of Pontiac fever, a non-pneumonic form of L. pneumophila infection. Legionella spp.’s mode of transmission is through aerosols or aspiration of contaminated water. The Public Health […]

The Indoor Mold Is An Early Warning Device

The mold (or mould, in the Queen’s English) has been the victim of a bad press. Mention the word and it conjures up an image of something rotting or in the process of decomposition. And yet, were it not for the mold that inspired the discovery of penicillin millions of lives would have been lost. […]

Copyright © 2025 . Mold & Bacteria Consulting Services (MBS). 1020 Brevik Place, Unit 1A, Mississauga, L4W 4N7. Log in